First Public Consultation

We are grateful to everyone who responded to the first public consultation, which took place between 16 October and 16 December 2024, on the draft Consolidated Standard, Assurance Process, and Claims Policy (formerly the reporting and claims policy), and Governance Model.

The consultation received a substantial amount of feedback from stakeholders and rights holders with a diverse range of perspectives. Detailed feedback was received from 192 stakeholders in 25 countries, with around 4,700 individual comments received. This substantial feedback helped shape improvements to the Consolidated Standard, Assurance Process and Claims Policy.

In line with ISEAL’s Code of Good Practice, the CMSI Partners have published a Consultation Report outlining the process and sharing key themes and insights from the feedback received.

Download the consultation report

Individual submissions

For full transparency, the Partners have made available verbatim submissions from respondents who gave their permission.

View individual submissions

High-level summary:

• 192 stakeholders submitted feedback during the 60-day consultation period, totalling just under 4,700 individual comments.
• Feedback was received in five languages from 25 countries, with a high volume of comments from Canada, the United Kingdom and the United States, and a diverse range of perspectives from South Africa, Brazil, Chile and Peru, among others.
• Input came from across the value chain: 25% of comments came from the mining industry, however we received notable contributions from other groups, including consultants (16%), NGOs/CSOs (16%), Indigenous Peoples/organisations (7.6%), the midstream/downstream industry (5%), and fewer but comprehensive submissions from governments, investors, labour and other standard setting bodies.
• The Consolidated Standard received the highest level of engagement, accounting for 87% of all comments, while the remaining 13% focused on governance, assurance, and reporting.

Final public consultation

The final public consultation on these documents took place from 8 October until 17 November 2025. Learn more about the final public consultation here.

To stay informed, please subscribe to our newsletter.

Draft documents: October 2024 (first public consultation)

Arabic	Standard Assurance Process Reporting and Claims Policy Governance Model (Combined)	English	Standard Assurance Process Reporting and Claims Policy Governance Model (Combined)
French	Standard Assurance Process Reporting and Claims Policy Governance Model (Combined)	Japanese	Standard Assurance Process Reporting and Claims Policy Governance Model (Combined)
Portuguese	Standard Assurance Process Reporting and Claims Policy Governance Model (Combined)	Russian	Standard Assurance Process Reporting and Claims Policy Governance Model (Combined)
Simplified Chinese	Standard Assurance Process Reporting and Claims Policy Governance Model (Combined)	Spanish	Standard Assurance Process Reporting and Claims Policy Governance Model (Combined)